Comments on: Old Books, the Antidote to Our News Feeds https://educationalrenaissance.com/2022/01/22/old-books-the-antidote-to-our-news-feeds/ Promoting a Rebirth of Ancient Wisdom for the Modern Era Sat, 06 May 2023 15:16:40 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.8.3 By: Patrick Egan https://educationalrenaissance.com/2022/01/22/old-books-the-antidote-to-our-news-feeds/#comment-1934 Tue, 25 Jan 2022 12:52:57 +0000 https://educationalrenaissance.com/?p=2627#comment-1934 In reply to Adam Beyer.

Adam, I have a couple thoughts that might contradict one another. First, I agree wholeheartedly that parent partnership always makes for a better educational outcome. The more continuity between home and school there is, the more the child benefits from things like the affective response to what is learned as well as from support of training in habits. That being said, I do think that even if the child has more (and potentially significantly more) scree time at home than is on offer at school, the classical approach remains pretty effective. The way I see it, when the direct instructional environment is by and large free from screens and devices, at least a significant amount of the day (and perhaps the most productive part of the day) is screen-free. At home, where the parents take a more prominent role in the discipleship of the child, perhaps there’s more scope for the child to be shaped in affections and habits despite a greater intake of media. On the whole, my preference is always for limited screen time, but like you point out, a perspective like Tech-Wise Family (which I highly recommend) helps to set up a philosophy of media, and not simply methods for limitations. A final point is that parents (and schools for that matter) should devote time and attention to equipping students as to how to approach devices and screen time. Otherwise, we might be delaying the inevitable onslaught of technology’s captivating glow.

]]>
By: Adam Beyer https://educationalrenaissance.com/2022/01/22/old-books-the-antidote-to-our-news-feeds/#comment-1916 Sat, 22 Jan 2022 19:46:14 +0000 https://educationalrenaissance.com/?p=2627#comment-1916 Dr. Egan, this is excellent and I couldn’t agree more with your insights here. My family has benefited from Andy Crouch’s perspective in The Tech-Wise Family. I see how classical education can be a part of the antidote. I’ve observed, however, a limiting factor regarding just how much classical education can remedy the abovementioned problem: parents. I believe that there needs to be continuity between a student’s classical education and his or her home environment. Classical education needs a robust partnership between the school and parents, including a unified approach to tech. Otherwise, a student may be feasting on great books and great ideas in a screen-free school atmosphere and then going home to starve on screens, social media, video games, and the like, all of which would then seem to significantly limit the depth of classical education’s formation. Would you agree with this observation? I’m eager to hear your thoughts on this.

.

]]>